Issues in Software Cache Coherence

Large scale multiprocessors can provide the computational power needed to solve some of the larger problems of science and engineering today. Shared memory provides an attractive and intuitive programming model that makes good use of programmer time and effort. Shared memory however requires a coherence mechanism to allow caching for performance and to ensure that processors do not use stale data in their computation. Directory-based coherence, which is the hardware mechanism of choice for large scale multiprocessors, can be expensive both in terms of hardware cost and in terms of the intellectual effort needed to design a correct, efficient protocol. For scalable multiprocessor designs with network-based interconnects, software-based coherence schemes provide an attractive alternative. In this paper we evaluate a new adaptive software coherence protocol, and demonstrate that smart software coherence protocols can be competitive with hardware-based coherence for a large variety of programs. We then discuss issues that affect the performance of software coherence protocols and proceed to suggest algorithmic and architectural enhancements that can help improve software coherence performance.